Toffee, fudge and filled chocolates, handmade on the Independence Square.
Pickens Sweet Treats. Sisters Natalie and Nanette handcraft their signature toffees, gourmet fudge and filled chocolates.
Open Tuesday to Saturday from 10 am
205 N Main St, Independence, MO 64050. Tuesday to Friday 10 am to 5 pm, Saturday 10 am to 4 pm. Far away? Order on Etsy and they ship it.
Signature toffee
Created in the Pickens sisters' kitchen. Every quarter pound is packaged on its own and hand packed, ready to give.
-
English Toffee
Their top seller. Soft, buttery toffee with the slight crunch of almonds and the finest dark chocolate.
Quarter-pound bag $9Half-pound box $17
-
California Cashew Toffee
Soft, buttery toffee with cashews and a touch of coconut, finished in white chocolate.
Quarter-pound bag $9Half-pound box $17One-pound box $31
-
Milk Chocolate Toffee
Buttery toffee in milk chocolate.
Quarter-pound bag $9Half-pound box $17
Made in a kitchen where nuts, milk and soy are used.
Gourmet fudge
$7 each, 4 oz.
Thirteen flavors on the shop's list this year. What's in the case changes, so call if you're after one in particular.
- Chocolate
- Chocolate Walnut
- Chocolate Mint
- Cocoa Coffee
- Cookies and Cream
- Missouri Mud
- Peanut Butter
- Rocky Road
- Salted Caramel Cashew
- Birthday Cake
- Cinnamon Caramel
- Malt
- Maple Pecan
Chocolates and more
- Sea Salted Caramels$8
- Dark Chocolate Peanut ClustersQuarter pound $8, or a pound for $30from $8
- Chocolate WafersMilk, dark or white$8.50
- Buzz BeansChocolate covered espresso beans$11
- Chocolate Dipped OreosMedium box$19
Gift boxes and baskets
Sweet-filled boxes and baskets for birthdays, holidays and Valentine's Day, or just because. Seasonal ones change through the year.
Just Because Gift Box
$29.99
You're the Best Gift Basket
$51.99
Two ways to get it
In the shop
On the Independence Square at 205 N Main St. Come in Tuesday to Saturday and choose from the case.
Get directionsShipped, through Etsy
Selling on Etsy since 2016, and shipping from Independence.
5,867 sales. Rated 4.9 from about 1,200 reviews.
Order on Etsy“Delicious! Best candy shop I’ve ever ordered from.”
“I send these to my mom as gifts. They’re her favorite, she says it’s the best chocolate she’s ever had!”
“Shipping took THREE days from MO to NYC and the chocolate is AMAZING!”
Figures and reviews from the Pickens Sweet Treats Etsy shop, January 2026.
Visit the shop
| Tuesday | 10 am to 5 pm |
|---|---|
| Wednesday | 10 am to 5 pm |
| Thursday | 10 am to 5 pm |
| Friday | 10 am to 5 pm |
| Saturday | 10 am to 4 pm |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Hours are Central Time.
- Address205 N Main St, Independence, MO 64050
- Phone(816) 260-5392
- Emailpickenssweettreats@gmail.com
- Order onlineetsy.com/shop/PickensSweetTreats
- FollowFacebook and Instagram